In This Episode
- Humans are still involved in hiring. Sylvain Maretto, a director of design, says AI screening produces low quality signals and that he trusts his own eyes, so write your resume and portfolio for people.
- Visibility builds your surface area for luck. Sarah's view is that showing up where hiring people spend time, like LinkedIn and niche communities, raises the chance the right people find you.
- A role with 1,500 applicants can still be worth applying to, since many applications from AI robo-applying tools are not from qualified people. In the interview, come prepared with two projects and ask which one the interviewer wants to hear about.
Episode Summary
The biggest thing that hasn’t changed in UX hiring is that people still decide who gets hired, even though AI is now part of the process. To mark episode 200, I went through my analytics and pulled back the most useful moments from recruiters and hiring managers, and I think the advice holds up whatever the trends are doing. If you work in UX or product, this is a good snapshot of where hiring stands today.
On the AI question, I played what Sylvain Maretto said about AI in hiring. He’s a director of design, and he shared his workflow and why he trusts his own review over AI matching. That means your resume and portfolio are still being read by a human, so you need to write for that person. I also share what Steph McDonald from HubSpot said about using AI to polish your own writing without letting it replace you.
Patrick Neeman, a UX director, described candidates who stood out because they built prototypes with AI and could walk him through their thinking. What mattered was showing the work, not claiming familiarity with a tool. I also talk about why a role can draw 1,500 applicants, why that number shouldn’t stop you from applying, and Jeni Bible’s tip for interviews: ask questions and let the interviewer pick the case study. Natalie Kurz adds what she looks for in portfolios now that she’s on the hiring side.
I close with visibility, which is one reason I keep making this podcast. If you want more from people on the hiring side, my conversation with Jared Tredly from Shopify is a good next listen.
Frequently Asked Questions
01Is AI deciding who gets hired in UX?
02Can UX job seekers use AI for their resume and application answers?
03How can I show AI skills in a UX interview?
04Should I apply to a job with hundreds of applicants?
05How can I stand out in a UX job interview?
Show Notes & Links
- Episode 168: UX Hiring Insights: Steph McDonald, UX Design Recruiter at HubSpot, on AI in Hiring, Portfolios & What Gets You Hired
- Episode 192: UX Hiring Insights: Sylvain Maretto, Director of Design, on Why AI Hasn’t Taken Over Hiring and What He Looks for in UX Portfolios
- Episode 199: How to tailor your UX resume for every job (and why keyword stuffing backfires)
- Episode 198: UX resume myths about the ATS, with Workday UX director and hiring manager Patrick Neeman
- Episode 155: UX Hiring Insights: Patrick Neeman on Soft Skills, Strategy & Hiring Red Flags
Episode Transcript
Sarah Doody [00:00:00]: Welcome to episode 200 of the Career Strategy Podcast. And when I started this podcast way back in March, 2023, I really thought that it would be a 12 episode thing, maybe 24. I frankly did not think I had the time to keep up with a weekly podcast, however, you guys said otherwise. You kept listening, you kept writing, you kept asking for more, you kept leaving great reviews. So here we are three and a half years later and now on episode 200. So if you’ve been listening from day one or you just discovered this podcast today, thanks. Thanks for coming along for the journey and I hope you stick around for another 200 episodes. Now because at heart I’m a user researcher, I didn’t want to mark this 200th episode without looking at some data. And so what I’ve done over the past couple of days is gone into my YouTube analytics, looked at the analytics on my podcast platform and I have identified some episodes that are pretty, pretty popular and curated some really important takeaways from recruiters and hiring managers and design leaders that I really think are timeless. Because if you’ve followed this podcast for a while, you know that I am not about throwing kind of trends out there. I am rooted in timeless things that I know are going to be useful to you so you can learn them now and apply them now in your job search or career, but also have them tucked away to be able to use in a year, two years, five years from now, who knows. So in today’s episode, we’re going to kind of break it into three parts. We’re going to talk about what has not changed in the job search, the impact or influence of AI in your approach to your UX job search and what has changed. So I want to start off with what has not changed in the UX job search. There’s a narrative going around in UX hiring and probably in other industries also that AI is screening everyone out and it’s taking over hiring and recruiters and hiring managers are barely involved in deciding who gets an interview or not. So I asked Sylvain Maretto, a director of design, what AI gets wrong in hiring and how he uses AI in hiring and he didn’t just give me an opinion. He told me his workflow and how he is using it. So let’s listen to what he had to say.
Sylvain Maretto [00:02:57]: So, I will take a real example of the last hire that I’ve done, but basically, the problem is that there’s no standard about what should a resume look like. Whether you do ATS ready with Google Doc or you do something fancy in Figma that cannot be read by an ATS, it’s the same. The AI is going to look, for my last hire, for signals around design system skills. So you, as the hiring manager or the recruiter, you tell the AI what to search, what are the signals that you want to have, and it’s kind of automated, but basically, you would have just a tiny mention of a design system that doesn’t even live in storybook, but just in Figma, and the AI will tell you, yes, the signal is there. This is low quality signals, therefore it’s noise. I trust my eyes better, and yes, I’m going to review maybe 50 people over a day or 60, you know, with the breaks or not. It’s going to take a lot of time, a lot of money. In fact, you need to factor in the panel that’s going to unite one, two, three, four, five times for the interviews, and then you get an idea of how resource intensive it is. I used to run a startup with some friends where we tried to match doctors and nurses with job openings, so we had to translate not only what do they want in life, do they want to work in a clinic in the forest or something, but also, is that diploma in cardiology in Vietnam compatible with working as a cardiologist in Germany? I tried to just get it to match candidates with job descriptions just to look like, hey, here’s the URL of the portfolio, here’s the resume. What can you tell me if it’s a good match or not? Results are still not as good as my eyes or even the eyes of someone in my team that is not trained. Human factor is still irreplaceable.
Sarah Doody [00:04:41]: All right, that is the context that a lot of people miss. We need to remember that people are still involved in hiring. Hiring has not been outsourced to AI, which means your resume and your portfolio are still being read by a human. So you need to write for those humans. And to make this episode actionable, I’m going to point you to two other episodes that would be useful if you are in the middle of writing your resume or your portfolio. So in episode 199, I spoke about how to tailor your resume for every job without keyword stuffing. And in episode 187, I broke down the myth that you need three to five projects in your portfolio, totally false, you do not, and I’ve been seeing people get interviews and offers with just one project in their portfolio. All right, I want to move on now to what has changed in the UX job search. What’s changed especially with the use of AI on both sides of hiring, right? So candidates are using AI, companies are using it too, and one of the questions I hear all the time is, okay, but how can I use it in my job search, right? So I interviewed Steph McDonald, a design recruiter from HubSpot, and she had one of the clearest answers that I’ve heard in a while. So let’s listen to what Steph said about AI in UX hiring.
Steph McDonald [00:06:22]: Yeah, I think that’s a, that’s a discretionary thing. So for example, if, if we’re applying and just needed to, I had an idea of how I wanted to answer a question and I put it through ChatGPT to kind of tighten it up a little bit, maybe make it a little shorter because I tend to go on, uh, that that’s totally fair play. I think, you know, again, it’s about, you know, AI being a tool, not being the candidate, right? So my preference, my advice is to write these things yourself. And then if you, if you feel like it needs some polish and some, you know, just tightening up, throw it through to ChatGPT. I don’t mind that, but just be really careful when you’re pasting it in that you’re only pasting the answer and not like the bot talk that happens on that. So yeah, I mean, you know, we, we want people that embrace AI that are excited to use these tools that are excited to build these tools. So yeah, that’s for us, there’s, we don’t, we don’t discourage people. We know people are going to use ChatGPT or other tools to be able to, you know, really make their resume polished or whatever. That’s great. We don’t mind that at all, but it shouldn’t replace you in the process and your decision-making process about what roles you, you want to apply for.
Sarah Doody [00:07:27]: All right, so to reiterate what Steph said, use AI to help you think, to play devil’s advocate, to help you evolve an idea, a sentence, but don’t just outsource all of your writing to AI, because recruiters like Steph are going to be able to spot it from a mile away and it’s not going to be a very good look. And beyond the resume, I want to think about other applications of AI as a candidate. And here’s what one application could look like in practice. I interviewed Patrick Neeman, who’s a UX director, who’s been hiring for AI roles. And I asked him if anyone had showed up to an interview with something they had built. And here’s what he had to say about that.
Patrick Neeman [00:08:19]: We had three designers that we interviewed recently that used AI to build prototypes and were able to walk us through it.
Sarah Doody [00:08:26]: Did you hire any of them?
Patrick Neeman [00:08:28]: Two of them.
Sarah Doody [00:08:29]: Amazing, amazing.
Patrick Neeman [00:08:31]: Yeah, they got moved up to the front because, you know, basically, I’m looking for a world where prototyping is actually more prevalent than Figma.
Sarah Doody [00:08:40]: Hmm. Interesting. Two out of three. That’s pretty great. So here’s a good follow up to that. So if you were hypothetically job searching, you know, on Monday, what would you do differently than maybe what you would have done five years ago, let’s say, or three years ago?
Patrick Neeman [00:09:01]: Five years ago, I would have gone in the Figma and taken all the stuff I worked on and polished it and put it in a deck. Today, I would build a Lovable prototype with the assets I have, get it as close to look and feel that I could to the application and actually record a video or walk people through it. Because there’s like literally those Lovable prototypes, they stop traffic. They are so amazing, because people get to see the story. And if you can practice the story with that, it’s actually super helpful.
Sarah Doody [00:09:33]: Now I want you to notice one important thing about what Patrick said that helped some of those candidates stand out and get moved to the front. He said it wasn’t that they had just used AI. They didn’t just say they were familiar with Claude or ChatGPT or whatever. What helped them stand out was that they had built something and could walk him through their thinking. That is so important. It’s one thing to say, you know how to do something, right? Oh, yeah, I know AI, I can use AI. It’s another thing to show up with evidence or the receipts and show someone the thing you made with AI and walk them through your approach to creating that thing. And for more on AI and specifically in hiring in your resume, portfolio, et cetera, I really encourage you to listen to these two episodes, and I’ll link them in the notes. First of all, episode 198, another one with Patrick, where Patrick busts the biggest myths about the applicant tracking systems, and in episode 192, you can hear my full conversation with Sylvain Maretto. I really encourage you to listen to my full interview with Patrick, that’s episode 155, Patrick goes into amazing detail in breaking down things like how the applicant tracking system works, how you should tweak your resume for the applicant tracking system, and more on how candidates can effectively use AI and demonstrate AI skills in their job search. All right, and to finish this episode, I want to focus on what has changed based on what hiring managers are telling me about their experience hiring UX candidates. And here is one thing that has not gotten easier. Jeni Bible, who is a UX manager, told me about one role that she was hiring for that got 1,500 applicants, and only 10 people got an initial interview. And so how do you become one of those 10 people? But before we get to that clip, why are there 1,500 applicants for a single role? There’s a couple of factors at play here. One of them is, of course, a supply and demand issue. But the other thing to think about is that now, because there are AI tools that can be robo-applying on the behalf of candidates, many of those candidates that those AI tools are submitting are not remotely qualified. So when you see a role that says there’s 500, 1,000, 1,500 applicants, don’t let that deter you from applying, because it’s highly possible many of those people were not qualified in the first place. But let’s listen to more about what Jeni Bible had to say, because her answer is very, very insightful about how you can stand out.
Jeni Bible [00:12:56]: Ask me about my team. Who am I working with? What is my day to day look like? How many meetings am I in? How many meetings does your team run? What’s your type of leaders? Like at that point I’m assessing you, you should be interviewing me. Do you want to work with me? You know, you may not like me and be like, I don’t know about this girl, right? Like you’re interviewing me just as much as I’m interviewing you. Do you, you know, is this a team that you feel like you want to join?
Jeni Bible [00:13:24]: So talking about the team, what projects that your work, that we’re working on and making sure, because some people, what I really appreciate is said, what are you working on? What is, you know, I think this is for, you know, payments, right? Like what specifically does it unpack that for me? So I want to pack it for me, for them. And then they will choose which case study to go on, or they’ll ask me, what do you think? This is, they’ll give me a little highlight of this one, a little highlight of this one and say, which one do you feel matches what you’re looking for? And then they let me pick and I’m like, that’s pretty, pretty smart. So I’ll pick the one. And then if that one’s, you know, kind of not giving me what I want, I’ll be like, well, tell me a little bit about this one. So, um, you know, just come ready with a couple things and you know, you can’t get it right, all the, you know, right off the bat, but if you have something that you’ve done your research and you know, you’re going to nail it because you already know the questions to ask.
Sarah Doody [00:14:22]: So if you do make it to that interview stage, I love Jeni’s tip. Basically, it boils down to consider your user and try to give them a tailored experience. So how can you do that? A couple of ways, right? You can be asking them follow up questions, making it a conversation, and letting them pick the case study. I think it’s such a smart strategy to go into a UX job interview prepared to talk about maybe two projects and asking that interviewer which one they might want to hear about. Because perhaps one of them is directly related to a problem or challenge that they are facing on their team right now that you may not know about. So consider your user. And I want to end with someone who’s been on both sides of hiring. Natalie Kurz went through Career Strategy Lab a while ago. She got hired, and now she is on the hiring side. And here’s what Natalie said she looks for in candidates right now.
Natalie Kurz [00:15:33]: And then once I got past that, I would then start reading a little more carefully the bullets and kind of looking for, can they quantify impact, right? That was something, and that is so hard as a designer, right? I struggle with that. But as a department lead now, like how can I quantify the impact of my department, right? So that is, I realize a tough ask for, to ask for other people, but even if it’s non-numerical impact, right, and more generic, at least understanding that your designs are being used by someone and what behavior, even say what behavior did it change, right? I was able to design this, and as a result, users could more easily complete blah, blah, blah, right? It doesn’t have to say I improved conversion rates by 22%, right? But not everyone gets to those types of metrics. So it was like, can they quantify the impact of their design? Can I understand their thought process? That was a big piece on the, once I started looking at the portfolios, right? Can they tell the story? Are they too focused on just the UI decisions that they made as opposed to the problems they were trying to solve, right? That was a key thing in the portfolio. I saw that a lot where it was like, I changed this, and I made a table like this. And then I, you know, as opposed to, I helped users solve this problem, or I did this type of research to learn this type of thing, right? So that, to me, was a lot more important than, let’s say, pretty screenshots. Pretty screenshots are nice, but they’re not the most important part when it comes to the portfolio, for me, at least.
Sarah Doody [00:16:56]: I think it’s also really important to remember that you never know when a hiring manager may be lurking, right? They may be reading your LinkedIn comments. They may be in a community that you also belong to. And what you say in terms of posts and comments on LinkedIn or in communities you belong to or even if you’re in a program like my UX job search accelerator program Career Strategy Lab, the questions you may ask on calls for example. All of those things are signals that may stick in the mind of a recruiter or a hiring manager. And they somewhat are a preview or foreshadowing of how you think. And that can either work to your advantage if you stand out as someone who is very thoughtful and inquisitive and good at critical thinking and things like that. It can also work against you if the things that you say in posts and comments and on calls are not strong representations of what someone like Natalie might be looking for in terms of skills on their team. So if you want to hear more from people who are involved in hiring, another great episode to listen to is episode 161 where I interviewed Jared Tredly, a design recruiter at Shopify. And another one is episode 143 with Heather Cassar who is a VP of people at a financial startup on what happens behind the scenes of hiring and especially how to navigate the job market when there appears to be so much competition, when in reality as I said earlier those 1500 people who applied, they are absolutely not all qualified. So episode 200, I cannot believe it. And a couple of takeaways, right, number one, humans are still involved in hiring. AI plays a role, but humans are still making the decisions. And AI has changed the tools in hiring for the people doing the hiring and for you, right? But you have to remember to not outsource your thinking to AI because it’s going to haunt you and more than likely it’s going to make you sound like every other candidate. And if you’re a recruiter or hiring manager vetting hundreds of candidates every time you open up a role, the people who stand out will be the ones who do not sound like every other candidate. So if you don’t want to sound like every other candidate, stop relying on AI to outsource all your writing, okay? And the third big takeaway here is that people who are getting hired and who are standing out are really focusing on relationships and focusing on visibility. And visibility is one of the things that I want to end us on here because people keep asking me, how do I keep up with this show? And it’s a lot of work, yeah, but one of the reasons I do it is because of visibility. This podcast helps new people find me. And it helps people keep me top of mind when they are stuck with their job search. And it also gives you a free resource if you’re not in a place to maybe invest in my UX job search coaching program, Career Strategy Lab. And another thing I’ll say is that because I’ve been doing this for a long time, and I also have a degree in marketing, I know that audio and video build trust faster, I believe, than just written word alone. So I’m not telling you to go start a podcast, but visibility works the same in your job search, right? It’s about showing up where the people who, in your case, hiring hang out, right? And that is probably LinkedIn. And maybe some niche UX communities, or maybe ones for your specific industry, whether that’s UX for healthcare, UX for finance, whatever it is. But one of the best tips I can impart for you is to think about where you can increase your visibility, because when you increase your visibility, you increase your surface area for luck. Maybe you’ve heard that phrase before, but when I think of surface area of luck, I think about increasing the chances that the right people are going to find you. And I see that happening, because people in my Career Strategy Lab program, when they optimize their LinkedIn profile and start posting more on LinkedIn, not 50 times a week, but just here and there, people who are looking for someone like them are finding them. I can count multiple people who have been literally found on LinkedIn by a recruiter, hiring manager, CEO, head of product. They were interviewed, and they got an offer. The power of visibility is so, so important. And if you want to take time to do one thing for me today, here’s what I would ask. Please go leave a review or a rating for this podcast. I don’t let companies sponsor this podcast. So many companies come to me with crappy AI products they want me to promote, and I tell them no, because I don’t want to fill this podcast with garbage ads for garbage products. So if you want to help me keep this podcast ad-free, then I really would love if you could go leave a review and a rating for this podcast. Just hit pause right now. Even if you just leave a star rating and don’t write anything else, that will help me so, so much. So thank you so much for helping me get to 200 episodes of the Career Strategy podcast. I will see you in future episodes, and who knows, maybe we will make it to 400. We’ll have to see.

